A high-level picture of physiological training load for runners

Runners and coaches throw around the term “training load” a lot, assuming everyone knows what they’re talking about. But when you start to dig into the meaning of that term, you end up with what you might call the “tempo run” problem—the term means something different for just about everyone!

In this article, I am beginning a three-part series on how to think about training load. I’m not going to laboriously cover the mathematics of every possible training load metric.

Instead, I want to present a high-level conceptual framework—specifically, my claim is that there are three types of training load that you should consider in training: physiological training load, biomechanical training load, and psychological training load.

Each of these types of training load has various ways of being quantified, and arguably various sub-components as well. The three types of training load also relate to one another in some interesting ways. But before talking about interactions, we need to understand each type of load on its own first.

Our topic today is the first of these three: physiological training load.

In short, physiological training load describes the stimulus experienced by the various biological subsystems of your body that contribute to energetics writ large: so, your bloodstream, your mitochondria, your lactate transport proteins, and even the primary motor cortex of your brain. Proper physiological training load drives improvement: gains in your body’s energetic capabilities that allow you to run faster and further.

See also: Part II - biomechanical training load

Read more

Calculating the effects of heat and humidity on marathon performance

How much does heat and humidity affect performance in the marathon? And how do we know how much those conditions affect marathon performance? These questions matter both for planning what marathon race you want to sign up for as well as for adjusting your pacing plan the week of the race once the weather forecast finalizes.

Below, I’ll make the case that the optimal temperature for marathoning is 35–55 degrees F, or 2–13 degrees C. Additionally, I’ll show that humidity is not a concern until the air temperature is above 65° F (18° C). These numbers come from an analysis of 3,891 marathon performances across 754 different races.

Read more

A runner’s guide to LT1, the first lactate threshold

LT1 is the first lactate threshold: one of two key thresholds that define your body’s pattern of physiological response to different running speeds (the other being steady-state max or “SSmax”).

Your LT1 can be intuitively understood as the boundary between paces that feel easy versus paces that feel moderate, steady, or strong.

On a physiological level, LT1 represents the point at which your aerobic system faces its first real disturbance to homeostasis.

Now, that does not mean that paces above LT1 are anaerobic—instead, your aerobic system rises to meet this challenge, and maintains an aerobic steady-state. However, the signs of this greater aerobic challenge become evident in key physiological metrics like blood lactate and oxygen consumption.

A number of my recent posts have brushed up against LT1, like my article on individual variation in heart rate zones, my transcript and commentary on Marius Bakken’s double threshold training, my article on physiological resilience for marathon runners, and of course my article linked above on SSmax, the other key physiological transition.

However, I haven’t done a full article yet dedicated to LT1, and since there’s a ton of wrongheaded information out there about exactly what LT1 represents, it’s high time we take a deep dive into the science behind LT1, the mess of various acronyms and terms related to LT1, and the practical relevance of LT1 for training.

Read more

Individual variation in heart rates at LT1 and LT2 in runners, and the implications for zone training

Crop tops under sports bras are the next big thing in running fashion, you heard it here first

The entire purpose of running by heart rate zones is to create a specific pattern of physiological response in your body when running in each zone. “Zone 2 training,” for example, has specific (purported) fitness benefits that are connected with the physiological responses seen below LT1, the first lactate threshold.

There is a similar connection between “Zone 4 training” and LT2: the purpose is to be close to, but not above, LT2, the second lactate threshold.

In Part I of this series on heart rate zones, we covered the science of maximal heart rate (HRmax), %HRmax, heart rate reserve (HRR), and %HRR. We also covered the science of LT1 and LT2 (which is really just a method of estimating SSmax), and why LT1 and LT2 must be at the foundation of any scientifically based zone training model.

(Note that reading Part I is not a strict pre-requisite; if you are familiar with the basics of %HRmax, %HRreserve, LT1, and LT2 you should be able to follow along just fine).

We concluded Part I with two simple questions: (1) what heart rates correspond to LT1 and LT2? and (2) can specific heart rate zones correctly position you below or above these key thresholds?

Our purpose in this article is to answer these questions. More specifically, we are interested in the individual variation in the heart rates that correspond to LT1 and LT2. It would be wonderful—and suspiciously convenient—if LT1 and LT2 corresponded to exactly 70% and 90% of HRmax, as some zone models claim. Unfortunately, heart rate zones are neither this convenient nor this consistent.

In short, LT1 and LT2 can occur at a shockingly broad range of heart rate values, even when expressed as %HRmax or %HRreserve. Here's the key data:

Threshold Maximal heart rate (HRmax): 90% range Heart rate reserve (HRR): 90% range
LT1 69 – 94% HRmax 65 – 90% HRR
LT2 80 – 98% HRmax 73 – 95% HRR

...and those are 90% ranges, meaning that one in ten runners will be outside these ranges!

If Zone 2 training is important to you, you need to be running at less than 70% HRmax, or less than 65% HRR to be 95% sure you are in Zone 2.[1]

These numbers come from a meta-analysis of 412 runners from 25 different scientific studies, the results of which I present below.

Read more

LT1, LT2, and the scientific basis of heart rate zones for runners

Heart rate zones are all the rage for many runners. Various experts and authorities tout the benefits of different “zones,” though exactly how many zones there are—and what heart rates define each zone—are points of vociferous disagreement.

Instead of tackling the behemoth that is heart rate training in one post, this article is focused on one narrow but critical aspect of heart rate training: how and why heart rate zones are connected to LT1 and LT2, the first and second lactate thresholds.

My goal is to convince you that the entire point of heart rate zones—as they are currently used and advertised—is to be able to tell whether you are running below LT1, above LT1, or above LT2. The (purported?) benefits and (supposed?) scientific rationale of heart rate zones in popular training advice is almost always couched, either explicitly or implicitly, in the physiology of LT1 and LT2.

We will focus only on the connection between heart rate, heart rate zones, and LT1 & LT2 as key physiological signposts. Our goals are to answer the following questions:

  • What is heart rate trying to measure?
  • Which measurements of heart rate are most appropriate for quantifying training intensity?
  • What is the purpose and underlying science behind heart rate zones as a concept?

Along the way, we will understand %HRmax, %HRreserve (%HRR), and some (but not all) of their flaws.

Read more

Individual variation in aerobic and anaerobic energy contributions to different events

Fast-twitch Frannie and Slow-twitch Sallie face off in an ultimate battle to discover who is truly the queen of the mile

Many books on training and exercise physiology (including mine) begin with a discussion of aerobic and anaerobic energy production. The next logical question to ask is how much these two energy systems contribute to the various running events—how “aerobic” is, say, the 800m? Such a question is sure to spark heated debate online, but I have always been skeptical of such figures, for two reasons.

First, some of the methods that were traditionally used to come up with the aerobic vs. anaerobic contribution to a particular event have not held up to scrutiny.

Take the concept of “oxygen debt”—the idea that you could measure anaerobic energy expenditure by measuring post-exercise oxygen consumption, as your body “paid” for its anaerobic energy production. This concept was known to be shaky as early as 1984, and though later research has improved on the accuracy of these metrics considerably, many of the papers that coaches and training books cite do not use these modern, improved methods.

Second, I have a broader disagreement with the search for one number: to say, for example that the 800m is “65% aerobic” (as Joe Vigil’s book does) or ~50% (as Coe/Martin’s book does) glosses over the fact that there is tremendous individual variation in how much aerobic versus anaerobic energy goes into a given event.[1]

In fact, that range of variation looks like this:

Event % Anaerobic (range for nine out of ten runners)
800m 15–33%
1000m 10–25%
1500m / mile 8–20%
3000m / 2 miles 4–10%
5000m 3–6%
10,000m 2–4%

Where do these numbers come from? Read on to find out!

Read more

New app for calculating threshold, CV, and VO2max pace

I’m excited to share my latest web app: a calculator for threshold pace, CV pace, and VO2max pace! 

📱 Check out my new threshold, CV, and VO2max calculator here! 📱

This calculator allows you to predict physiological training paces from any race distance from 800m to 10 km. 

This app was developed by analyzing over 10,000 race performances using the critical speed model, the gold standard in physiology for determining metabolically stable and metabolically unstable paces. 

The app also includes uncertainty ranges so you can get an idea of the range of different physiological profiles that you might find among runners at the same level of performance.

Below the app, you’ll find a detailed write-up of how it works and what differences you’ll notice between this app and other CV pace, threshold pace, and VO2max pace calculators and tables that you might’ve used in the past. 

As with all of my apps, it is 100% free and open-source. If you find any bugs, have any suggestions for improvements, or spot something that doesn’t look right,  drop me an email. 

Read more

Predicting threshold pace, CV pace, and VO2max pace from 5k times

Most serious runners do workouts at threshold pace, CV pace, and VO2max pace. But how can you know if you're running the right pace for your threshold, CV ("critical velocity," a.k.a. critical speed), or VO2max sessions? There are plenty of conversion charts online, but it's not always clear whether they're making predictions that are accurate for most runners.

This article introduces a simple framework for determining threshold, CV, and VO2max pace based off your current 5k fitness, using percentages of 5k pace to set workout paces. Below, I'll show how these three training paces can be derived from the critical speed model, and present an analysis on thousands of race performances that result in the following training guidelines:

Pace Estimate Meaning Also known as
Threshold 90% 5k Fastest pace that produces a metabolic steady-state SSmax, LT2, CS-, T pace
CV pace 96% 5k Boundary separating metabolically sustainable and unsustainable paces CS, critical speed
VO2max pace 100% 5k Slowest speed that produces metabolic instability and drives oxygen consumption to VO2max CS+

Don’t forget that I have a handy pace percentage calculator for quickly calculating pace percentages!

These predictions are accurate for >90% of runners ("accurate" here meaning "producing the intended physiological effects") and come from data on hundreds of runners with 5k PRs from 14:00 to 25:00. They'll probably work pretty well outside that range too.

Naturally, these predictions work great for full-spectrum percentage-based training, but they work just as well in other systems too.

Want to know where these calculations come from? Read on!

Read more

Physiological resilience was ready to be discovered over 30 years ago

Earlier this year I wrote about the concept of physiological resilience—your body’s ability to resist deterioration in its fitness level over the course of multi-hour races like the marathon.

Since the concept of resilience was first proposed in a paper last year, there’s been a flurry of new research on it, confirming that it does seem to be an independent component of fitness, beyond the “usual suspects” of VO2max, running economy and steady-state max (SSmax).

Resilience is an extremely simple and elegant explanation for a common problem: people slow down at the end of the marathon because their fitness level is deteriorating.

A pace that used to be metabolically sustainable at the beginning of the race is no longer metabolically sustainable at the end. Moreover, the ability to resist this deterioration varies from person to person, and is amenable to training.

As I was putting together some writing for another project, I was reviewing some of the initial research on the experimental data on the rate of deterioration in running economy and VO2max.

I realized something remarkable: three key scientific papers that form the backbone for the arguments behind physiological resilience all came out in the same year—and that year was 1991, over 30 years ago. Resilience, as a conceptual model, was just sitting around waiting to be discovered for three decades!

Read more

Calculating the effect of headwinds and tailwinds on running pacing and performance

Headwinds and tailwinds are fundamentally an issue of air resistance and drag forces—physically pushing aside the air in front of you when you run imposes an additional energetic cost on your body. Air resistance is an issue even in calm conditions: the faster you run, the more costly it becomes to overcome air resistance, since you’re essentially creating a headwind for yourself.

🍃 This article explains the science behind my headwind and tailwind calculator. Check it out if you haven't already! 🍃

It’s super easy to use, but under the hood, it does some pretty sophisticated calculations. This article covers the science behind these calculations, and acts as a primer for understanding air resistance in running: where it comes from, how to calculate it, and how it’s affected by headwinds and tailwinds.

This article goes deep into the physics and bioenergetics behind air resistance in running. If all you want to do is calculate how headwinds and tailwinds affect your pacing, the web app is all you need. Otherwise, if you want to learn everything there is to know about air resistance in running, then buckle up!

Read more

Check out my new book on marathon training!